In this article, I am describing the difference between core type and shell-type transformer.
In an earlier tutorial, we have studied the electrical transformer and its construction. Under construction and winding, transformer are classified into two types such as-
- Core types of Transformer
- Shell types of Transformer
Let see each of those factors.
Difference Between Core type and Shell Type Transformer
These two transformer types are classified based on transformer construction.
The transformer can also be classified into different types based on measurement, cooling system, electrical power, and winding. Check the classification of the transformer for more detail.
In a tabular form, you can learn the topmost 16 different points for core type transformer vs shell type transformer.
|Sr. No.||Content||Core Type Transformer||Shell Type Transformer|
|01||Magnetic Circuit||In a core-type transformer, a single magnetic circuit occurs in a series form.||In a shell-type transformer, the double magnetic circuit occurs in parallel form.|
|02||Magnetic Flux||The magnetic fluxes flow in only one magnetic path.||The magnetic fluxes flow in two different magnetic paths.|
|03||Construction||In this transformer, windings surrounded by the Core.||In this transformer, the core surrounded by windings.|
|04||Winding Types||The concentric or cylindrical types of windings are used in core type transformers.||The sandwich or disc types of winding are used in shell-type transformers.|
|05||Copper Winding (conducting material)||It requires more copper for windings.||It requires less copper for windings as compared to the core type transformer.|
Applications (Voltage rating )
|It is used for high voltage applications.||Usually, it is used for low or medium voltage.|
|07||Cooling System||Core type transformer can easily provide a natural cooling system (like Air) for winding.||Shell-type transformer can’t easily provide the natural cooling system for winding.|
|08||Core Limb (or Legs)||The core consists of two limbs in a single-phase transformer.||The core consists of three limbs in a single-phase transformer.|
|09||Insulation||It requires less amount of insulation materials due to construction of LV and HV windings.||It requires more amount of insulation materials over the core type transformer.|
|10||Maintenance||It requires less maintenance as compared to the shell-type transformer.||It requires more maintenance.|
|11||Repair||It is easy to repair. You can easily remove and replace the coil from the core.||It is very difficult to repair. You can’t easily remove the coil from the core.|
|12||Power Output||It gives low output power.||It gives high output power.|
|13||Losses (Copper and Iron Losses)||
More losses occur in core types of transformer.
|Fewer losses occur in shell types of transformer.|
|14||Power Efficiency||Core type transformer has a low power efficiency due to less output power and high leakage flux.||Shell-type transformer has high power efficiency due to high output power and low leakage flux.|
Note: Learn here different type of Transformer losses in detail
15. Lamination Design of Transformer
‘L’ shape lamination is used for core type transformer design.
‘E’ or ‘I’ shape lamination is used for shell type transformer design.
16. Circuit Diagram of Core Type and Shell Type Transformer
Circuit Diagram of Core Type Transformer
Circuit Diagram of Shell Type Transformer
I have covered 16 points in core type transformer vs shell type transformer.
Related differences to read:
- Series Circuit Vs Parallel Circuit
- Electrical Circuit Vs Magnetic Circuit
- Alternating Current Vs Direct Current
- Single Phase Circuit Vs Three Phase Circuit
- Transmission Line vs Distribution Line
- Underground Cable vs Overhead Line
Online Quiz to test your knowledge:
If you are ready to give the online quiz, you can directly join electrical Transformer Quiz.
If you have any queries related to the difference between core type and shell-type transformer, kindly share in the comment section.
Thanks for Reading!
I have completed master in Electrical Power System. I work and write technical tutorials on the PLC, MATLAB programming, and Electrical on DipsLab.com portal.
Sharing my knowledge on this blog makes me happy. And sometimes I delve in Python programming.