As a part of the railway electrification technical series, in this article, I will explain Indian Railway electric and diesel-electric engines with specifications.
Also, will cover the following concepts such as…
- What is the difference between the electric locomotive and diesel locomotive?
- Which is better- diesel or electric locomotive?
- Advantages and disadvantages of electric and diesel engines
Let’s begin,
Difference between Electric and Diesel Locomotives
| # | Content | Electric Locomotive | Diesel Locomotive |
| 01 | Source | As its name, the electric locomotive works on electricity. | The diesel locomotive works on the diesel. |
| 02 | Powered by | The engine of the electric train requires electricity through overhead lines. | The engine of the diesel train does not require direct power or electricity from overhead lines. |
| 03 | Power Generation | This type of locomotive does not generate the own power. | This type of locomotive generates self-power by using diesel fuel with a two-stroke or four-stroke engine. |
| 04 | Requirements | It requires less equipment like a transformer, circuit breaker, compressor, etc. | For power generation, more types of equipment like a piston, generator, radiator, etc are required |
| 05 | Weight | The electric engine is lightweight. | Usually, the diesel engine is heavy in weight. |
| 06 | Effect | The electric locomotive does not produce heat and noise as compared to a diesel locomotive. | The diesel electric locomotive produces heat and noise. |
| 07 | Impact | This electric train is pollution-free. | This diesel train emits pollution. |
| 08 | Maintenance | It requires less maintenance. | It requires more maintenance. |
| 09 | Overhead System | The electric locomotives constantly require an overhead contact system. | The diesel-electric locomotives do not require an overhead contact system. |
| 10 | Cost of electric & diesel locomotives | Electric trains are cheaper. | Diesel trains are expensive. |
| 11 | Electric & diesel train speed | The electric train speed is higher than the diesel-electric train. | The diesel-electric train speed is lower than the electric train. |
| 12 | Weather impact | Under weather conditions or terrains, an electric locomotive is not much beneficial than a diesel locomotive. | Under weather conditions or terrains, a diesel locomotive is very beneficial than an electric locomotive. |
13. What are the parts of electric & diesel electric locomotives?
- Locomotive Electric Engine Parts
Pantograph, Circuit breaker, Compressor, , Battery, Transformer, Cooling fan, Motor blower, Rectifier, Inverter, Insulators, Three-Phase AC Motors, DC-DC Converter, Bumpers, Coupler, Trolley Poles, Axle brush, etc are the most important parts of the electric train engine.
- Locomotive Diesel Engine Parts:
Diesel engine, Fuel tank, Air intakes, Radiator, Radiator fan, Turbocharger, Alternator or generator, Rectifiers, Inverters, Air compressor, Electronic controls, Control stand, Sandbox, Gearbox, Traction motor, Air Reservoirs, Motor blower, Batteries, Driveshaft, Truck Frame, etc are the useful parts of the diesel-electric train engine.
This is all about the difference between electric and diesel locomotives in India railway.
These points also cover the advantages and disadvantages of the electric locomotive over the diesel-electric locomotive.
Which is better diesel or electric locomotives?
The electric and diesel locomotives have different specifications, as we already seen.
When considering speed, effect, power source, environmental condition, and performance, both locomotives have some benefits and drawbacks.
I have already briefly explained each point. We conclude that the electric locomotive is better than the diesel-electric locomotive. Day by day, the number of trains running with the electric locomotive engine is increasing.
If you want to include any points about the diesel vs electric locomotive India, you can drop the comment in below.
Read some related electric difference:
- Alternating Current vs Direct Current
- Transmission Line vs Distribution Line
- Synchronous Motor vs Induction Motor
- Core Transformer vs Shell Transformer
- Single Phase vs Three Phase AC System
- Overhead Line vs Underground Cable
- Star Connection vs Delta Connection of AC System
Thanks for Reading!
I have completed master in Electrical Power System. I work and write technical tutorials on the PLC, MATLAB programming, and Electrical on DipsLab.com portal.
Sharing my knowledge on this blog makes me happy. And sometimes I delve in Python programming.
Hi Dipali
It is great that you are interested in locomotives and how they work.
In New Zealand we have diesel and electric but only about fifteen electrics.
Good luck with your electrical engineering career.
Regards
Brian